Since all my programs are now out, I might as well contribute to this for next year's peeps. I think my advice would be that if you're not one of those crazy amazing applicants, just apply to a lot of programs and don't be picky
Total Apps: 56
Programs applied who have offered interviews: 56
Rejections: if I had to go back and count all of these I'll cry
Interviews Offered: 20 + interviewed at one away
Interviews Declined: 3 so far
USMLE: Step I 247, Step II - not taking until March
Grades: Preclinical - mostly P; Clinical - I only honored ortho and fluffy stuff like geri...everything else is HP except for medicine and pedi (oops)
Med School: was a Top 10 USNWR when I started

AOA: Nope
Away Rotations: 2
Publications: 2 ortho manuscripts pending acceptance, one abstract rejected from AAOS; some ER research from undergrad that actually got accepted places
Letters: 4 ortho
Awkward in interview: mildly.