Don't know anything about Syracuse but do know something about Beaumont. In my opinion, Beaumont is one of the strongest programs in the entire country. Here's why:
-It is a level-1 trauma center w/ tons of trauma. They have three young fellowship-trained traumatologists that very willing to teach--esp. those interested in trauma.
-At any given time during the week, there are 10-15+ ortho ORs being used. HSS and Mayo are the only two institutions that do more ortho surgery than Beaumont. There are many more cases than there are residents.
-They have multiple attendings in every subspecialty (2 peds, 2 tumor, 3 trauma, 1 shoulder, 3 hand, multiple joints, multiple spine, multiple sports, etc.)...all friendly and willing to teach.
-The facilities at Beaumont are top-notch. ORs are brand-new and state-of the art. ORs and ortho floor are in brand new $300 mill south tower. Must see it to believe it.
-The ancillary staff is motivated and helpful. e.g. ORs are turned over in around 20 mins.
-They have a brand-new biomechanics lab if research is your thing.
-Everyone at Beaumont (inc residents) is happy to be there. The hospital has tons of money and its employees are treated well.
-many more pluses
You should definitely check out Beaumont...