I said, "you are ranked very high on my list." I think you're right "top of the list" implies #1.

Based on the responses I've received, I think they're just happy to know that they're well thought of in you're eyes - and they appreciate being kept in the loop. And, this is hearsay, but making your interest known in any capacity can help move you up a rank list...

-Bill

I told them they are in my top two or top three or whatever. Very highly is ambiguous and I am sure they get letters fro everyone sayin very highly regardless of where they actually are.

I told them they are in my top two or top three or whatever. Very highly is ambiguous and I am sure they get letters fro everyone sayin very highly regardless of where they actually are.

Do you guys think people actually read these emails or thank you letters. I have heard from more than one person at high ranking programs they rarely even read them and the ones they do read are from people they remember and already thought highly of so where does that get you in the end? you're already golden.

I think many actually read them and a good % respond. Usually it is a message conveying interest and gratitude for the e-mail you sent them, but in a vague manner that certainly fails to give you a clear picture as to where you stand.

I guess the argument you present is why send them since it seems they have low impact if any?

I think most agree that for the most part these applicant to program communications yield low impact. The counter argument is that perceived low impact is better than no impact. It takes little time and effort for the applicant, and I can't imagine how it would ever produce a negative outcome, somehow moving you down the list. Therefore, extremely low risk with low reward and in rare cases, perhaps moderate reward. Question becomes, why wouldn't you?

Obviously, if a % of PD's find it simply annoying, and it actually could move you down the list, then this clearly changes the equation.

I would only contact the number 1 program unless the others contact you. I dont think telling anyone they are number 2 helps you. However by only contacting the number 1 they know where they stand, and the other programs that are high on the list dont know that they are not number 1. Telling programs they are high on the list is not fooling them, i would not do that.