Micky,
Dude that hurt. What did I ever do to you
?
No seriously, that has something to do with it. And I agree that some of the programs that they have ranked high deserve it (mayo, harvard, iowa, ccf, etc.). Others, like a certain program in detroit that shall remain nameless, don't deserve to be on the list. And I think that some (like myself) when applying don't know the difference between a great ortho program and a great ortho residency training program. The US NRP seems to be geared more towards ranking good programs. With that said, I did use the US NRP as a starting point to figure out which programs I was going to apply to.