I graduated the Einstein (Bronx) program this past June, so I'm a biased in answering your question. I had a great experience there...as most recent grads will agree. The training is excellent, with a wide range of cases. It's top heavy, so PGY2 year is REALLY tough (lots of call), but 3rd year is much better and 4th and 5th year, you will mainly operate.
I'm in fellowship right now, and I must say that I feel well prepared and pretty comfortable in the OR and in conference. Everyone's passed the boards in the past 5 years, and we get good fellowships.
PLUS, you're in NYC...
Feel free to contact me with questions.
Good luck