Wow, this area seems to evoke some REALLY strong feelings.
Unfortunately most of the people writing seem to be ortho residents or affiliates.
Now for the real deal...from a PGY-5.
You guyz have probably forgotten how many MS4's would do just about anything for A SINGLE ortho spot.
I applaud you for "getting the word out" on the situation in Detroit, however, when black monday comes, and the unlucky few don't get a spot, I can guarantee you that they'd rather be at a back stabbing, uncaring program, than doing research, prelim surg or some other uncertain pathway hoping to get into ortho.
I have had the opportunity to sit in on and perform ortho interviews this year and can assure you that candidates are doing everything to get in... Many were humbled to find themselves unmatched last year, while others knew they had little chance but keep trying anyway.
And lets not talk about the FMG's. I've met FMG's in the labs that have been trying for ortho >6years... Step I & II scores >240, Few if any interviews. I can assure you that if this "god awful" program does reopen, it will fill.
Besides, a program is what you make of it.
I think some of us already in ortho have forgotten the trail we blazed.
Personally, this was the only medical career option for me...and I know that I would've given anything and gone anywhere as an MS4, just for the opportunity to do ortho.
-Hulk